Note the similarity in the speeches of Lucetta and Portia; Julia and Nerissa.
4. What are your conclusions?
That Shakespeare liked the scene in the
earlier play and therefore developed the same situation when he wrote The Merchant of Venice. That Shakespeare used
whatever he liked or whatever "took" more than once.
5. Why is this an important scene?
Because it tells the audience that Proteus, the devotee of love, is to be separated from
the woman he loves and, therefore, raises the questions, "How will he act?" "What
will he do?"
ACT II - SCENE I
6. What shows you that Valentine's love for Silvia is genuine?
Valentine's failure to see through Silvia's
device (see lines 121-140) suggests that
his love for her is genuine.
7. What is the reason for giving this short scene?
In order to show Proteus and Julia together. After hearing his speech, lines 8-12, an audience would be further interested in the questions raised at the end of Act I, Scene iii.
8. What kind of humor is found in this scene?
9. Do you enjoy it?
Natural, homely nonsense. If one sees
the clown leading his dog by a string onto
the stage, the quibbling wit of the speeches
will probably cause laughter.
10. How does Thurio reveal his character, lines
By his speeches, especially lines 12, 20 and
30. In the first he shows jealousy; in the
second, stupidity; in the third, anger.
11. Would comedy of this kind interest a modern audience?
It would depend upon the way it was played. The words read probably seem
uninteresting but the action which goes with the words on the stage would cause laughter. This scene shows the absolute
necessity of visualizing a play.
12. Which character is the more interesting, Valentine or Proteus?
The answer will depend upon the reader; whether he is more interested in seeing
treachery punished or honesty and love rewarded. Both are interesting.
ACT IV - SCENE I
13. How does Shakespeare make Valentine's willingness to become an outlaw less objectionable, lines 71-76?
By a reference to the romantic robber
Robin Hood, by the statement of the
Third Outlaw that some of the band are
gentlemen (lines 44-61), and by the agreement to
". . . do not outrages
On silly women or poor passengers."
14. Summarize the ways by which the story is complicated.
The introduction of Thurio as the chosen suitor of Silvia; the arrival at Milan of Proteus, and his immediate determination
to supplant Valentine; Julia's trip to Milan in search of Proteus; Thurio's appeal to Proteus for aid in his wooing;
Proteus's failure to recognize Julia and his giving her a position as his page ; Silvia's escape from her father's court, her
capture by the outlaws, and her rescue by Proteus; these events make up the complications.
16. What feelings are aroused by lines 68-112?
Satisfaction and sympathy. Satisfaction,
because Silvia tells Proteus what she
thinks of him and his actions; sympathy,
because Julia hears the man she loves declare his love for another, and because she
also hears Silvia tell Proteus what he is.
16. Does Proteus deserve the reward he receives?
No. The mere statement of repentance is
not sufficient punishment.
17. Will Julia he happy with Proteus?
Probably not. At least, one cannot be certain that Proteus will treat her well; but perhaps she would be happy with Proteus under any circumstances.
18. Do you like the way in which Shakespeare
ends the play?
Many do not; to them the end seems to be forced and weak.
19. Are there any scenes or characters which seem
Some of Valentine's actions seem unnatural, see Act III, Scene i; Act V, Scene iv, lines 78-83; the Outlaws all seem unnatural; Eglamour does not live up to the reputation given him in Act IV, Scene iii, lines 11-13. Act III, Scene ii; Act IV,
Scene i, seem unnatural.
How to cite this article:
Lunt, Forrest. Shakespeare Explained. New York: Hearst's International Library, 1915. Shakespeare Online. 2 Aug. 2011. (date when you accessed the information) < http://www.shakespeare-online.com/plays/twogent/gentlemenquestions.html >.